” All That Man Is” And #ManBookers2016 Finale

So I have completed the Man Bookers’ prize list shortlisted books. By completing , I mean I have read 5 books & the final book “Do not say  we have nothing” was not available in India till last month, so I have moved to other books, & now it’s too late to read it before the finale which is on 25th Oct. So, I am going to present a short review of “All That Man Is” by David Szalay followed by my prediction of the winner.



This is the collection of 9 short stories, all centered at men who are away from their home. You can see the gradual progression in the age of the central characters of each story. The first story is of the teen age backpacker & the last story is of someone towards the end of the life. Each story contributes a characteristics which may be either common or uncommon among the men universally, but not unheard of.

Before reading this book, I had read Eileen & Hot Milk which were both centered around young women characters. Both characters were the narrators of their stories & were very candid & honest about their shortcomings & insecurities. But men in this book are different- they are indecisive, delusional, pitiable & dishonest. You can feel how uneasy they are with realities & how they try to shield the world they see. I enjoyed most of the stories in book- they were well paced & had a good blend of the humor & despise.

I rated “All that Men Is” is solid 4 out of 5 stars- Nine men from nine stories trying to portray the man of this era.

Prediction Time

So, here is my final standing of all the shortlisted books:

  1. The Winner- “His Bloody Project” by Graeme Macrae Burnet (My goodreads rating- 5/5 stars)
  2. Hot Milk” by Deborah Levy ( My goodreads rating- 4/5 stars)
  3. “All that Man Is” by David Szalay (My goodreads rating- 4/5 stars)
  4. Eileen by Ottessa Moshfegh (My goodreads rating- 3.5/5 stars)
  5. The Sellout by Paul Beatty (My goodreads rating- 3/5 stars)

Did Not Read- “Do Not Say We Have Nothing ” by Madeleine Thien

Overall On The Man Bookers’ Prize Shortlist


First time in many years, I have enjoyed the most of the shortlisted book. Maybe I have matured more as an reader or maybe jury has changed it’s parameters. I can see the variety of voices in these books & they are all telling the tales that are relevant to this generation. I am very confident that my prediction will be wrong ( It always go that way) but in “His Bloody Project” we have a great material & the new art of storytelling that will influence many stories in the future ( Did anyone buy the movie rights yet for this book ? )

I hope you enjoyed this series. Will love to read your comments.

11 Comments Add yours

  1. There was a time when I used to read the nominated books but not anymore. These days I have thoroughly enjoyed No. 1 Ladies Detective Agency series. Do check out if you have time.


    1. I have not read “No 1 ladies detective agency series”. I will try it though. Thank you


  2. I’m woefully behind.

    All I’ve read is a bit of the ‘Hot Milk.’ Still haven’t finished it!


    1. Will love to know your views on “Hot Milk”once you read it. It has got a very mixed reviews so far. Thank you for stopping by 🙂


      1. I loved her Levy’s Swimming Home, and she signed my copy of Hot Milk, so I might be a tad biased…but will try my best not to be. I’m a fan of her writing (and her reading), so…yep.


      2. I enjoyed “Hot Milk”but have not tried Swimming Home yet. I can sense that there is definite novelty in her writing. (wee bit jealous about your signed copy though 😛 )


      3. Hehe sorry was such a show-off. But I hardly ever get to chat about books, so I’m hoping you’ll forgive my over-excited chatter.

        Liked by 1 person

      4. Swimming home IS MARVELLOUS.


      5. Haha..no no it is okay to show off. I would have done the same. I am adding Swimming Home to my reading list. Thank you for the recommendation 🙂


  3. I am a pretty slow reader reading books in my own sweet time but I like how your review ‘All that man is’ sounds. Will check on the other book recommendations too. Thanks for this list!


    1. Yes, do check it, however from the list, if you have to choose one, i will recommend “His bloody project”.


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s